Intro for LinkedIn: As changes to Canada’s Competition Act place growing responsibility on businesses to substantiate their ESG claims, it’s more important than ever to ensure your ITAD and recycling data are backed up by clear records. Here’s a checklist for gathering the evidence you need for defensible claims.
Year-end Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) reports are an opportunity to showcase the environmental benefits of responsible IT asset disposition (ITAD). Claims such as “zero e-waste to landfill,” “1,200 devices given a second life,” or “40 tonnes of CO2e avoided” can demonstrate meaningful progress toward corporate sustainability goals. But how confident are you that every published figure can be traced back to reliable documentation?
For businesses, the stakes are becoming higher. Canada’s Competition Act now places specific substantiation requirements on certain environmental claims, and ongoing debate over the legislation has highlighted the potential compliance, reputational, and financial risks associated with sustainability reporting. Even with recent amendments, organizations must be prepared to demonstrate that their environmental statements are accurate and supported by evidence.
The best defense is a well-organized documentation process. Here’s how to build an evidence file that supports your IT recycling and reuse claims.
Why IT disposal claims are easy to get wrong
The original numbers provided by an ITAD vendor may be accurate, but problems can arise as information moves between departments. Diversion weights, reuse totals, and avoided-emissions estimates may be rounded, reworded, or combined before reaching sustainability and communications teams.
Without a clear audit trail, organizations may struggle to connect a published statement to the original documentation. That creates unnecessary exposure when stakeholders, regulators, or other interested parties question the accuracy of a claim.
What’s expected by the Competition Act
In 2024, Bill C-59 introduced new anti-greenwashing provisions to Canada’s Competition Act. Initially, certain environmental claims about businesses and their activities had to be supported by an internationally recognized methodology.
Bill C-15, which received Royal Assent in March 2026, removed the specific methodology requirement, replacing it with the standard of “adequate and proper substantiation.” It also removed private access to the Competition Tribunal specifically for claims under this provision, although other avenues for challenging misleading environmental representations remain.
While these changes address some of the concerns about regulatory uncertainty, they don’t eliminate the obligation to support environmental claims. In other words, businesses still carry the responsibility of substantiating applicable claims, making accurate documentation essential.
Diversion and recycling weights: What to hold
To ensure compliance, a landfill diversion claim must have more than a general statement from your recycling provider. For each material stream, you should also have pickup weight records, certificates of recycling, and downstream processor documentation.
Additionally, define “diverted” in writing, including whether your calculations count equipment reuse, material recycling, and energy recovery. Be particularly cautious with “zero landfill” statements, which require evidence covering every relevant waste stream, including residual materials.
Make device reuse counts verifiable
If your organization reports that 1,200 devices received a second life, you should be able to identify those devices individually. To do so, request serial-number-level records distinguishing equipment redeployed internally, resold to another buyer, or sold through an employee purchase program. Count each device only once, and keep reuse separate from equipment dismantled for parts or materials.
Show your work behind avoided-emissions figures
Avoided-emissions estimates must have transparent calculations. Document the methodology, data sources, assumptions and reporting period behind every CO2e figure, and retain the original calculation output.
Terminology matters, too. Avoided emissions aren’t interchangeable with emissions reductions or carbon offsets, and should therefore never be used to substantiate a carbon-neutral claim.
Understand what certificates and certifications prove
A certificate of data destruction demonstrates secure information destruction, not environmental performance. Similarly, R2v3 and comparable certifications apply to specific facilities and approved activities. To that end, be sure to verify that the facilities handling your equipment were appropriately certified and that their certifications were valid when the work occurred.
Create a claim-to-evidence worksheet
A standardized worksheet helps sustainability, IT, and communications teams verify claims before publication. Here’s a table you can reference when creating yours.
| Field | Information to capture |
| Public claim | Exact wording |
| Reported figure | Weight, device count or CO2e |
| Reporting period | Applicable dates |
| Source document | Certificate, weight ticket or calculation |
| ITAD provider | Vendor responsible |
| Internal owner | Person verifying the claim |
Any claim without a supporting source document should be rewritten or removed.
Keep your evidence file ready
Documentation should be collected throughout the year, not assembled at the last minute. Assign responsibility for reviewing environmental claims, establish an appropriate record-retention policy, and schedule an annual verification process before ESG reports are published.
Finally, ask your ITAD provider for reporting that separates results by serial number, facility, and material stream. Having this information readily available makes it easier to validate figures and respond to questions.
Credible sustainability reporting requires more than impressive numbers. As environmental claims receive greater regulatory and public scrutiny, organizations need to demonstrate exactly how their reported outcomes were achieved. With Quantum’s GHG Reduction Calculator and reporting, customers receive detailed reports with information broken down by reuse and recycling, so data can be easily understood and communicated to stakeholders. Get a detailed look into our ITAD process and request a consultation here.